Foundations

Making Good Ideas Go Viral

A less-traveled path to education reform: The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation is catalyzing three social forces to create an epidemic of best practice.

Ashoka founder and CEO Bill Drayton recently wrote about his vision for a “changemaker world”—a place where problems can’t outrun solutions. He told a story about Ali Raza Khan, an entrepreneur in Pakistan, who tasked 6,000 poor students with starting successful ventures. He explains how, with little more than hearty encouragement, the students managed to develop the necessary skills and resources to achieve an 80 percent success rate. 

Imagine what would happen if we were to replicate Ali’s changemaker spirit among the 3.2 million American teachers in the United States. At the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, we have been wrestling with how philanthropy might help individual, effective teachers spread their changemaker spirit and best practices to other classrooms. Is the answer systemic reform, or is there an alternative way?  

Typically, philanthropists rely on the following strategies to carry out their work: 

  1. Policy change. Whether from a new law or legal decision, policy often drives shifts.
  2. Direct implementation. Through pilot projects, proof points, or replication, funders make specific investments in places or systems.
  3. Technical assistance. Funders invest in high-capacity providers that can support the shifts broadly.
  4. Tool development. Funders support new tools to meet new demands.

These strategies, familiar to any funder, represent clear bets on easily identified partners. Advocacy organizations are always hungry for foundation funding to support their efforts to shift policy; districts and schools are constantly looking for resources to pilot new tools or make system changes; organizations that offer technical assistance are easy to find, but capacity and quality of services vary; and entrepreneurs aren’t shy about knocking on doors for seed funding. 

But there’s an important fifth strategy that gets less attention: “contagion” or “viral spread.” In the philanthropic context, this is when good ideas or practices take on a life of their own, and spread widely from person to person. Viral spread is more likely to happen organically when it begins with individuals or informal networks—the #BlackLivesMatter and Occupy Wall Street movements are good examples. Philanthropists don’t use this strategy as often as others, because we typically want more control over and accountability for outcomes, but our foundation has been experimenting with how to work with teachers to create viral spread of best practices as part of our K-12 strategy. 

By “encouraging contagion,” we’re of course applying positive characteristics to a term that normally describes the spread of disease, thinking of it not as a negative force but as a process for creating “an epidemic of best practice” among teachers. Embracing the phenomenon of contagion requires that leaders relinquish some measure of control. It also demands that they stop thinking of change as a process related only to systems, markets, and policies, and start thinking of it as one driven by and affecting people. Contagion asks philanthropists to rely on the collective power of people to bring about change—to depend on a “group genius mindset” that’s more bottom-up than top-down.

The challenge for leaders of social change now is to know when we should rely more heavily on viral spread than on traditional strategies, and how much to invest in making it occur. 

In pursuing our larger education goals of supporting skilled teaching and establishing goals for student success, we’ve employed traditional strategies to bring about change. The adoption of the Common Core State Standards, for instance, gave us a policy lever that encouraged innovators to come up with new tools for meeting the standards. And in a typical direct implementation strategy, we funded several districts and states to help them implement the Common Core, and develop better teacher feedback and observation systems.

But our work with teachers is as much about developing skill as it is will. Research shows teachers want greater access to high-quality resources to improve their practice. They also crave connections with other teachers and trust each other more than administrators or external professional development providers. We also learned that some teachers are particularly influential in embracing change and working to improve. This is the perfect context for a bottom-up, contagion strategy.

Encouraging contagion isn’t as nebulous or capricious as one might think. It’s actually a calculated set of strategies that harnesses at least three social forces: influencers, people who make change happen; narratives, to help people understand what is happening and what is possible; and networks, to carry the work beyond direct implementation. For best practices to spread virally, we have to catalyze all three of these social forces.

Teacher leaders are crucial to viral spread, so we’ve been investing in developing more of them. Among the initiatives are the Literacy Design Collaborative (LDC) and the Math Design Collaborative (MDC)—frameworks designed to help teachers improve their practice. Thanks to teacher-influencers, the LDC and MDC tools have spread from just a few districts to dozens of states, and up to 30 percent of teachers say they are now aware of them. We’ve also cultivated teacher leaders through a conference by and for teachers called Elevating and Celebrating Effective Teachers and Teaching. Sessions include TED-style talks by teachers describing why they teach and the difference they make, as well as peer-led “colleague circles,” in which teachers help each other find solutions to challenging problems. Teachers leave the conference feeling part of a larger professional community. 

We’ve also made it a priority to meet teacher leaders who are active on social media. We’ve learned that you have to go where teachers are and that teacher influencers on social media have a different reach than teachers leading changes in a specific school or district. Teacher leaders are the most credible distributors of high-quality tools, whether their network is online or on the ground.

We’ve also listened carefully to teachers, in-person and online, to understand their values and beliefs—their narratives. We funded a research project that analyzed more than 12,000 teacher blog posts, 16,000 Twitter chats, and 24,000 tweets over a three-month period. In the process, we met a number of new influencers, and we heard three dominant narratives: Teachers deserve professional respect, are most effective when they collaborate as learners, and need ways to advance without leaving the classroom. These views have helped shape our investment strategies. We know we must support teachers in articulating their narrative so that they can propel their profession into the next phase of innovation and improvement.

Finally, in our efforts to virally spread effective instructional practices and tools, we’ve funded more than 40 teacher practice networks; these networks seek to improve teaching and learning, and view teacher leaders as critical to that endeavor. Teacher practice networks include formal organizations like the National Board for Professional Teaching Standards and longstanding organizations like the National Writing Project, as well as newer networks such as Edcamp and YouCubed. Through their collective expertise and connections, these networks help teachers tell their stories and bring effective practices to places in which we don’t directly invest.

Supporting networks gives teachers opportunities to collaborate and take on leadership roles; they also facilitate the viral spread of best practices. (Photo courtesy of the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation)

We should not underestimate the role of influencers, narratives, and networks in our efforts to bring about social change. Weaving together these three elements creates a powerful force in any scaling strategy. It’s too easy for philanthropists and other leaders to discount these forces in an effort to focus on systemic reform or products to help teachers do their jobs. It’s also too easy to ignore or discount the possibility of contagion when we so value accountability and control. But ultimately funders are just that—funders. Other people do the actual work. So why not try to balance our top-down strategies with bottom-up ones that are more viral and organic in nature? The reality is that whether we want to or not, these powerful forces are already at work, building changemaker mindsets around the world. Change might happen faster if we paid more attention to supporting and amplifying positive narratives, influencers, and networks.

Tracker Pixel for Entry
 
 

COMMENTS

  • Carina Wong's avatar

    BY Carina Wong

    ON March 18, 2016 11:06 AM

    Excited to hear your thoughts….

  • Cheryl Stephens's avatar

    BY Cheryl Stephens

    ON March 20, 2016 07:12 PM

    Hi Carina
    I am excited by your student success focussed work and would like to discuss further with you

  • BY Ryan Makhani

    ON March 23, 2016 01:25 PM

    Hi Carina. This is a remarkable finding - Teachers deserve professional respect, are most effective when they collaborate as learners, and need ways to advance without leaving the classroom. Thank you for all that you do!

  • Patrick Methvin's avatar

    BY Patrick Methvin

    ON March 23, 2016 07:51 PM

    Great article Carina.  Given the issues of control (noted above) that may make this approach difficult for some funders, do you have any guidance for investment developers (organizations in the field or program officers at foundations) on how to be effective in “pitching” these types of investments to the investment decision-makers (Foundation boards or managers with approval authority)?

  • Carina Wong's avatar

    BY Carina Wong

    ON March 24, 2016 01:03 PM

    I just left Hahrie Han’s keynote on social transformation at the Carnegie Networked Improvement conference. Her book How Organizations Develop Activists is a must read! A frame that might be helpful is to think about “bottom up change” v “top down” and to think about social transformation and not tool adoption. She opened with a powerful statement that I think relevant to my article: “Catalytic change happens not when we sell people products they already want but instead when we transform what people think is possible.” Isn’t that what we seek to do?

  • BY Astrid Scholz

    ON March 24, 2016 03:14 PM

    Carina - great article! We’re creating a platform for just the contagion you talk about, build on the underlying principles of reducing barriers to serendipity, accelerating the spread of solutions, and increasing the density of high value interactions. Would be great to chat sometime!

  • carina wong's avatar

    BY carina wong

    ON March 24, 2016 04:43 PM

    Happy to talk! Send me a link to your work and an email address and we can keep the conversation going…

  • BY Astrid Scholz

    ON March 24, 2016 05:59 PM

    Hi Carina—please take a look at our website (http://www.sphaera.world), and the “front door” into the platform at (https://resilience-exchange.sphaera.world). I’m at .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address), and look forward to continuing our conversation.

Leave a Comment

 
 
 
 
 

Please enter the word you see in the image below:

 

SSIR reserves the right to remove comments it deems offensive or inappropriate.
 
 
 
 
Defining Risk in Philanthropy - Thumbnail
Foundations

Defining Risk in Philanthropy

Featuring Steve McCormick

Steve McCormick, president of the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation, discusses what risk really means to both nonprofits and foundations, and why foundations should take more risks.

Efficient Philanthropy - Thumbnail
Foundations

Efficient Philanthropy

Featuring Nancy Roob

Nancy Roob, president of the Edna McConnell Clark Foundation, talks about the foundation’s True North Fund, which allows investors to put money into a pool fund that can then support multiple organizations and increase efficiency.

Leadership Is Everything - Thumbnail
Foundations

Leadership Is Everything

Featuring Mario Marino

Mario Morino, co-founder of Venture Philanthropy Partners, discusses how important leadership is to the culture, performance, and success of an organization.