It has been 16 years since social impact bonds (aka pay-for-success contracts) debuted in Peterborough, United Kingdom, where they were used to reduce recidivism among former offenders. At the time, the innovative new model for social financing garnered headlines from the Financial Times to The New York Times and cross-party admiration as a promising way to use private capital to improve social services in the era of post-Great Recession austerity.

The debate about their effectiveness has been a continuing topic in SSIR’s pages. Search on our website for “social impact bond” and you will get hundreds of results. To be sure, most of these instances come from articles written before the ascendancy of right-wing populism worldwide that turned political interests toward other priorities. Nevertheless, the model is alive and kicking, to judge from our Fall 2025 feature on social impact bonds addressing the health and well-being of First Nations peoples in Northern Canada.

So I was taken aback when Tracy Palandjian and Jake Segal of Social Finance, the nonprofit that invented the model, pitched us an article that asked whether social impact bonds were ultimately a failure. Despite the sunny headlines the idea originally commanded and its continued use to this day, it simply did not take off as Social Finance had hoped. Once occupying all their time, social impact bonds now account for 5 percent of their business. They did not scale. Why?

Palandjian and Segal tell the story of what happened. Each contract was a bespoke product requiring intensive data crunching, negotiations over what counted as success, and time to get it right. Social impact bonds were too complex, too labor-intensive, too tricky to satisfy the needs and interests of all parties—investors, politicians, and social-service providers—in a suitable time frame. Not a recipe for scaling.

However, the story does not end there. The authors argue compellingly that we should see social impact bonds as an important part of a larger outcomes movement that continues to transform how government, nonprofits, and philanthropies measure, define, and hold parties accountable for success in improving human welfare. What’s more, with the advance of AI, the data research that used to take someone like Segal weeks, if not months, now only takes days. Did social impact bonds fail? Perhaps it is too early to say.

Don’t miss our other features in this issue. In “1 + 1 = 3,” Hibah Khan, Jason Jay, and Idongesit Sampson of MIT Sloan team up with Dominic Hofstetter of the TransCap Initiative and Jonathan Rose of the eponymous real estate firm to advocate for investors to look for and harness combinatorial effects (“the amplification … of outcomes produced when multiple interventions interact”) to generate greater impact and returns.

And in “Mission Critical,” Ann Mei Chang, formerly of Candid; Ami Dar of Idealist.org; and Jim Fruchterman of Tech Matters call for nonprofit leaders to consider what is best for the nonprofit ecosystem as they address the ongoing funding crisis.

From the special print feature package “Mission Critical,” read “Learning to Let Go” by Chang and Dar and “Letting Go for Good” by Jim Fruchterman

Read more stories by David V. Johnson.