Illustration of human figures holding up colorful balls (Illustration by Brian Stauffer) 

Ten years ago in Seoul, Google’s AI-powered AlphaGo defeated Lee Sedol, the Go grandmaster. Since then, debates over what machines can do—and how much human activity they might replace—have only intensified. At a Yidan Prize conference held at the same venue where that historic Go match took place, Brookings Institution Senior Non-resident Fellow Elizabeth King posed a question we are all still reckoning with: If machines can do more and more, what is education for?

For education funders, that prompts an inescapable follow-up: With ideas, evidence, and technology at everyone’s fingertips, where does philanthropy fit?

Philanthropy is hardly in danger of becoming obsolete. If anything, the need for it has never been greater. Budgets are tightening across the sector, while many grantee partners are navigating withdrawn public funding, legal uncertainty, and deepening need. Precisely because every dollar must now go further, philanthropy needs to take a hard look at its role, purpose, identity, and, specifically, its shortcomings.

After all, education does not lack ideas; it may hold more transformative ones than at any point in its history. Evidence about how children learn and develop has never been stronger. Yet every experienced funder carries two private lists. There are the ideas that never scaled: the promising pilot that ended with a change of minister, the coalition that dissolved over ego and credit, and the well-designed model that never made its way into practice. And there are the challenges we have barely begun to address: the environmental factors that can stifle learning, from community violence and fixed mindsets in the system to socioeconomic inequality and political polarization.

These are not failures of imagination. They are not even failures of money. They are failures to build the trusted relationships that make change possible.

Where Philanthropy Fails First

In our experience, education philanthropy often fails relationally before it fails technically. Initiatives lack inclusive representation. Programs stall when leadership changes. Competition, acknowledged or not, fractures consortia. Grantees hesitate to speak unwelcome truths because the relationship cannot bear the weight of honesty. None of this appears in an evaluation framework, yet the costs are real: duplicated effort, abandoned learning, and communities understandably skeptical of the next well-funded arrival. When resources are scarce, relational failure becomes even more costly. There is less slack to absorb what mistrust wastes.

We are not suggesting that funders impose strict metrics for trust. Some of what matters most resists measurement, a tension explored in greater depth elsewhere in this volume. But funders can at least ask, with the same discipline we bring to financial statements: Are people more meaningfully connected than when we found them?

We have begun to call this practice relational philanthropy. It means treating authentic relationships—among funders, grantees, governments, and communities—as a primary asset and defining—and refining—our own roles in local contexts as a key responsibility. This relational approach sets the framework for collaboration—as a starting point of a shared journey rather than a means to achieve stated outcomes in collaborative philanthropy. It is not a byproduct of trust-based grantmaking, but something we deliberately build and honestly assess.

Shifting relationships and mindsets is well recognized as a critical condition for change in most systems-change frameworks. The parallel with education’s own reckoning is striking: Just as schools must move beyond a factory model toward relational approaches that cultivate judgment, creativity, and connection, philanthropy must move beyond transactional models toward relational ones.

What does this look like in practice? Our two organizations differ, and our activities vary widely. We have found that adopting a relational approach does not mean working in the same way. In fact, one of the strengths of relational philanthropy is its ability to support collaboration in different forms and contexts, with trust at the core.

Imaginable Futures works to build stronger, more equity-centered education ecosystems. In Kenya, we prioritized relationships with local researchers, educators, youth advocates, funders, and government to reimagine and reshape an education-research ecosystem led by, for, and with Africans. In 2026, this group launched Harnessing Education Research for Impact (HERI), a collaboration that aims to increase African-led education research from 3 percent to 30 percent of global output by 2050, a milestone for a continent increasingly authoring its own educational future. A vision of this scale and the creativity and collaboration required to pursue it among so many actors could not have emerged without strong relationships.

In Brazil, our partners helped us identify an opportunity to strengthen coordination and influence critical education policy. We supported seven organizations—many led by Black, Indigenous, and Quilombola communities—to come together, strengthen their relationships, and move forward collectively. During the 2025 revision of Brazil’s 10-year National Education Plan, more than half of the 300 amendments they collectively proposed were approved—a significant win for equity in education.

We don’t own either result, but we accelerated both by creating the conditions for trust and collaboration. Neither would have been possible without years of building relationships with the communities where we work, including with other funders.

The Yidan Prize Foundation nurtures a different kind of change platform, one grounded in recognition and trust. Yidan Prize laureates form a community that transcends disciplines and geographies. With proven track records in research and development, many are deeply embedded in their systems and already driving change at scale. In Senegal, laureate Mamadou Amadou Ly and his colleagues at ARED have shown that children who first learn in a familiar language before being introduced to French make significant gains in literacy. The Yidan Prize judging committee honored their work and brought greater attention to multilingual foundational learning. For us, however, the cash award and no-strings-attached project fund are just the beginning of a lifelong relationship with Mamadou and an opportunity for the foundation to understand the reality he is facing, learn about his community, and support his mission.

Nine months later, we convened 300 partners in Dakar with ARED and ADEA (Association for the Development of Education in Africa), under the auspices of Senegal’s Ministry of National Education. Six laureates brought their expertise and networks to the community and the convening, which pushed language to the forefront as a vehicle for learning, identity, and dignity, advancing a continental and country-led agenda now more widely recognized and supported by ministers, educators, researchers, and funders.

This article, like every contribution to this volume, raises questions without offering neat answers. Rather than a conclusion, then, we offer three propositions for other funders to test, contest, and improve—including against our own practice.

First, treat relational capacity as part of due diligence on a par with financials. What networks do potential partners already have? How are they building trust with communities, educators, ministries, funders, and peer organizations? And do we reward systems orchestrators who intentionally build social capital and trust in the ecosystem?

Second, evaluate and design partnerships to outlive our involvement. A consortium that dissolves when its funding cycle ends—or that dictates the direction of travel—is unlikely to be doing the long-term work that lasting change requires. A truer measure of a funder’s impact is the strength of the ecosystem—its relationships, capabilities, and local institutions—that remains after we are gone or when the border is closed.

Third, hold space for difficult conversations. Do we undervalue contribution and over-index on attribution, or vice versa? Why? How do we know we did not turn a relational approach into an insular network of individuals and institutions? What do we do when we are unable to surface specific roles for ourselves, failing to move beyond understanding toward actions? Some big questions are not meant to be answered and then filed away. They are checks and balances.

How Well We Connect

In the opening essay of this supplement, Isabelle Hau names a capacity we believe is critical but often unnamed: relational intelligence. She made a similar argument at the Yidan Prize conference in Seoul: Education systems must cultivate this deeply human ability in learners to build trust, navigate tension, repair rupture, and make meaning together. It is a compelling addition to the exploration of renewing public education’s purpose in a recent Stanford Social Innovation Review series.

As funders, we must cultivate relational intelligence in ourselves and help build it throughout education ecosystems at every level.

Investing deliberately in our capacity to connect may be one of the most valuable investments we ever make—to unlock enduring initiatives that weather leadership transitions, inclusive alliances that withstand competition and tackle environmental challenges, and the possibilities that artificial intelligence could transform society for the better.

Read more stories by Bruce Au & Amy Klement.