(Illustration by Brian Stauffer)
Learning is a deeply human process, and evidence is mounting that relationships, emotional safety, and meaningful purpose are fundamental to how we learn. So why is it still so difficult to design schools around these foundations? And why do some promising innovations stall at the pilot stage while others become part of public infrastructure? What allows an innovation to scale? California’s effort to redesign secondary schools around relationships, meaningful learning, and connections to community and careers offers a compelling answer.
Why Redesign Schools?
To understand how schools might be redesigned, we must first ask: What is education’s purpose today? As the Hewlett and Stuart foundations recently explored in these pages, education is essential to human progress. It helps us build cooperative communities and thriving economies in a world shaped by the COVID-19 pandemic, climate change, rapid technological and economic change, and global conflict.
Meeting these challenges requires moving beyond industrial-age school designs toward models that support meaningful, empowering learning and supportive relationships, and that can address a tide of mental health challenges, chronic absenteeism, and learning loss.
This is particularly urgent in secondary schools, where too many young people still experience a series of disconnected daily encounters, moving from one overloaded teacher to another and absorbing bits of information they rarely have opportunities to connect or apply. A typical US high school teacher sees more than 120 students each day, making it nearly impossible to know most of them well.
Meanwhile, the emerging science of learning and development—drawing on neuroscience and developmental and cognitive science—has shown that supportive relationships, emotional safety, and cognitive challenges connected to meaningful purpose are not peripheral to academic learning. They enable it.
During adolescence, when the brain is particularly plastic and the capacity for learning is extraordinary, strong relationships can foster both attachment to school and rigorous learning. Mastering challenging content requires productive struggle; to engage in that struggle, students need to trust their teachers and the learning process. These conditions matter for all young people, and especially for students for whom schools provide additional support, including learners with disabilities, students still acquiring English, and those who have experienced significant adversity.
None of this is new. For at least a century, philanthropy has sought to spur school redesign. Innovations that create small learning communities, supportive systems, project-based instruction, and authentic assessment have been piloted across the country. Some have survived and thrived, providing strong evidence of improvements in students’ attachment to school, achievement, graduation rates, and college-going. Yet none has scaled to transform education systems more broadly.
How California Is Bringing Redesign to Scale
California’s statewide initiative to redesign secondary schools around relationships, meaningful learning, and connections to community and careers offers important lessons in how to bring innovation to scale.
Part of an ambitious state agenda for public education, the initiative combines expertise in secondary-school redesign with a massive investment in community schools—slated to soon reach 60 percent of the state’s public secondary schools—as well as investments in college and career academies. In a policy environment that is typically fragmented, California has pursued a more strategic and collaborative approach to scale. Rather than treating these efforts as separate policy initiatives, the state has deliberately connected them around a vision of schools designed to foster strong relationships among students and adults, meaningful connections with families and communities, and clear pathways to college, careers, and civic life.
These current efforts—stimulated by government, philanthropy, researchers, and innovative practitioners working together—build on two decades of experience developing new school models: piloting and researching them, expanding what worked, providing technical assistance, and studying and scaling them further.
There is now substantial evidence from across the United States that well-implemented community schools—bringing together the resources of government, families, and community organizations to support the whole child—can produce positive outcomes.
In California, an early pilot launched during the pandemic grew into a $4 billion state investment, reaching 2,500 schools by 2025. These schools provide health, mental health, social-service, and academic supports for children and families, alongside community-connected, project-based learning. Their work includes before- and after-school care, summer school, social-emotional learning, restorative practices, and family engagement, all of which can strengthen relationships and foster a sense of belonging. Funders including the Stuart, Hewlett, and Ballmer foundations have complemented this work by supporting school learning and formal research.
A 2025 Learning Policy Institute (LPI) study of the initial grantees found that gains in attendance and achievement at newly funded community schools significantly outpaced those at similar schools, with particularly strong gains among Black students and English learners.
In 2026, community schools became part of the state’s core state funding formula, and the program expanded again, extending eligibility to more than 6,200 high-poverty schools. The governor and legislature also called for secondary community schools to receive support through a newly funded Secondary School Redesign Pilot program focused on relationship-centered designs and deeper learning.
The pilot currently includes 14 redesign networks that have already helped create hundreds of innovative schools. The state, together with the Youth Thriving Through Learning (YTL) Fund, a partnership of 12 foundations, is helping these networks support other schools seeking to undertake similar redesigns.
Among the redesign networks is California’s Linked Learning initiative, which works with business, community, and university partners to create academies that connect college and career pathways with real-world learning.
Within small learning communities, teachers work in teams that share a common group of students. Each teacher also serves as an advisor to a small group over multiple years, ensuring that every student receives sustained, personalized support. Alongside project-based learning in academic courses, students take dual-credit courses with local universities and pursue internships in local businesses and civic organizations, building portfolios that demonstrate their work. Teaching and learning are relational, community-connected, experiential, and empowering.
Launched by the James Irvine Foundation in nine districts in 2009, these models proved so successful that the state invested $500 million in 2014 to expand the approach. Foundations including Stuart and Noyce supported research, evaluation, and technical assistance, while the Linked Learning Alliance was established to provide technical support and manage a quality-certification program. In 2022, the state invested another $500 million to launch academies focused on STEM, green technologies, health professions, and teaching, building on Linked Learning practices. Most of these academies are, or will soon become, community schools as well.
Linked Learning has now grown to more than 600 pathways serving more than 330,000 students in more than 80 districts. New research finds that these models are producing stronger high school attachment, achievement, attainment, and post-secondary success.
Redesign in Practice at Oakland High School
When evidence-based approaches are implemented together, they can rapidly expand opportunities for young people. Oakland High School provides a vivid example.
In this school of 2,600 students, young people learn in small learning communities supported by a group of core teachers who also serve as advisors to groups of students, providing social-emotional support and help connecting families with the school.
In grades 10-12, students enter pathways in which academic coursework is project-based and connected to internships with local industries. Options include public health, law and social justice, environmental science, innovative design and engineering, or visual arts and academics. The graduate capstone initiative, in which seniors complete a yearlong research project tackling a community issue, provides a north star for high-quality project- and problem-based learning rooted in authentic civic engagement.
The Environmental Science Academy, for example, focuses on community environmental health, including at nearby Lake Merritt, where the students collect water-quality samples and work with the city to solve problems. In the Law and Social Justice Academy, students surveyed their classmates and teachers and analyzed federal policies to develop recommendations for better serving students experiencing homelessness. The district adopted their recommendations.
When students engage in work that is meaningful to them and have the relational supports they need, they are more motivated to take on academic challenges. Achievement follows. A recent LPI study found that Oakland High has made steady gains in student outcomes since its redesign.
At a school where 90 percent of students are low income and 7 percent experience homelessness, the four-year graduation rate in 2024 was 86 percent—above the district average and on par with the state average. Among the school’s graduates, 59 percent met admissions requirements for the selective state-university system, compared with 52 percent statewide. Student achievement also exceeded pre-pandemic levels in both English language arts and math, with gains outpacing district averages.
Teacher retention has risen to 90 percent as well, as teachers find greater success and motivation in their ability to build strong relationships with one another and with their students.
Innovative schools such as Oakland High exemplify LPI’s guiding principles for whole-child design: creating structures for relationships and belonging, such as small learning communities, multiyear advisories, and looping arrangements in which teachers stay with students for multiple years; connecting learning to purpose through projects and internships that give schoolwork authentic purposes and audiences, helping students see that their contributions matter; and integrating supports, so that services are seamlessly available to students and families rather than fragmented across disconnected offices.
But understanding what works is not enough to produce widespread change. Innovation is not a model to be replicated so much as a system that must be built, continuously adapted, and improved. California’s experience shows how different actors can contribute to that process: Philanthropy stimulates innovation; government creates space for experimentation and learning; leaders and practitioners develop and adapt new approaches; research builds evidence and implementation knowledge; and ultimately, government incorporates what works into durable public infrastructure.
From Innovation to Infrastructure
There is an American myth that innovation will somehow scale itself in the public sector. Experience has repeatedly proved otherwise. Scaling what works requires supportive policy, sustained investment, and the capacity to learn and adapt along the way. Research can be a critical driver, providing evidence of what works. Philanthropy can help build the relational infrastructure and expand the supply of new approaches to teaching and learning.
In California, new school models began as pilots supported by philanthropic and federal funds. Early research helped shape them into state initiatives, which then expanded through multiple rounds of state funding. As the models spread across the state, further research identified the models that mattered most and informed technical assistance to help schools put them into practice. That expansion also exposed obstacles created by decades of regulations built around the factory model of schooling. The state can now use what it has learned to remove those barriers and make more relational approaches easier to sustain.
At their best, schools are communities designed around trust, connection, and belonging, where students can thrive academically, socially, emotionally, and physically. Schools across the country have shown that these models of redesign can work. The challenge now is not to invent new strategies—we have those—but to build the conditions and momentum to bring them to scale. That means forging durable partnerships among philanthropy, research, practice, and government so that promising innovations can become the public infrastructure of education.
Read more stories by Linda Darling-Hammond & Elena Silva.
